Originally Posted by
Zippyjuan
There is definitely some BS, and its coming from Zippy. The article re Vietnam that Zippy cites gives a range between 1.5 million to 3.6 million. The 1.3 million Zippy cites is a low estimate and does not even include Laos or Cambodia. Further, even the US defense secretary during the war, Robert McNamara put the Vietnamese death toll at 3.4 million.
"According to a Vietnamese government statement in 1995 the number of deaths of civilians and military personnel during the Vietnam War was 5.1 million. (2)Since deaths in Cambodia and Laos were about 2.7 million (See Cambodia and Laos) the estimated total for the Vietnam War is 7.8 million.
The Virtual Truth Commission provides a total for the war of 5 million, (3) and Robert McNamara, former Secretary Defense, according to the New York Times Magazine says that the number of Vietnamese dead is 3.4 million. (4,5)"
Korea: "During the war the bulk of the deaths were South Koreans, North Koreans and Chinese. Four sources give deaths counts ranging from 1.8 to 4.5 million. (3,4,5,6) Another source gives a total of 4 million but does not identify to which nation they belonged. (7) John H. Kim, a U.S. Army veteran and the Chair of the Korea Committee of Veterans for Peace, stated in an article that during the Korean War the U.S. Army, Air Force and Navy were directly involved in the killing of about three million civilians both South and North Koreans at many locations throughout Korea
It is reported that the U.S. dropped some 650,000 tons of bombs, including 43,000 tons of napalm bombs, during the Korean War.
Lastly, trying to argue that a particular intervention only mass killed 1.3 million people instead of more, is not a vindication for mass killings. Its like trying to defend 9/11 by arguing the death toll is not as high as some people calculate.
Connect With Us