Results 1 to 13 of 13

Thread: Meet Adam Curtis, Socialist documentary filmmaker masquerading as "Establishment Contrarian"

  1. #1

    Meet Adam Curtis, Socialist documentary filmmaker masquerading as "Establishment Contrarian"

    You may know his work from such films as "The Century of the Self' discussing Edward Bernays.

    I just want to say right now, beware of this man's work. It will make you a misanthrope, and he equates free market ideas to game theory, which assumes anyone who does whats in their self interest becomes greedy, conniving, manipulative, and distrustful of others.

    His new film, "The Trap" goes over this in detail.



  2. Remove this section of ads by registering.
  3. #2
    Quote Originally Posted by Son_of_Liberty90 View Post
    You may know his work from such films as "The Century of the Self' discussing Edward Bernays.

    I just want to say right now, beware of this man's work. It will make you a misanthrope, and he equates free market ideas to game theory, which assumes anyone who does whats in their self interest becomes greedy, conniving, manipulative, and distrustful of others.

  4. #3
    Quote Originally Posted by timosman View Post
    I forgot to mention he took a dig at Hayek and even tied Hyek's theories to the origin of game theory. Very manipulative.

  5. #4
    Quote Originally Posted by Son_of_Liberty90 View Post
    I forgot to mention he took a dig at Hayek and even tied Hyek's theories to the origin of game theory. Very manipulative.
    How so? Humans have this tendency to take shortcuts. Eventually everything becomes just a game.

  6. #5
    Quote Originally Posted by timosman View Post
    How so? Humans have this tendency to take shortcuts. Eventually everything becomes just a game.
    True but for Curtis to say that Hyek's ideas of Austrian economics were co-opted by game theory social scientists is misleading.

    Hayek and the austrian ideas were to say that rational self interest without coercion established good relations among people to benefit themselves and others. Curtis uses his narrative of Cold War social scientists adopting Austrain principles in the 1950's to develop game theory established from then on rational self interest turns us all into greedy, conniving, manipulative, and distrustful human beings. That would, in effect, nullify any theory of libertarianism and anarcho capitalism discussed on RPF.
    Last edited by Son_of_Liberty90; 12-14-2016 at 11:04 AM.

  7. #6
    Blairwatch: In the films you suggest that this narrow idea of freedom and the economic theories used stem from game theory�

    Adam Curtis: They stem from right wing economists like Friedrich Hayek, that's the sort of utopian vision as an alternative to communism. What Game theory provides is what seemed to be scientific proof that this vision would work because what Hayek is saying is instead of having planning we should just allow people to behave as they wanted and out of that would come order. That was his vision. What Game theory suggested was, well, that's true� and that's what I try and say.

    Blairwatch: Game theory, starting as a mathematical formula seemed to be spread into so many other areas of research, from genetics to economics to war planning etc.

    Adam Curtis: It seems to offer an explanation of how you can have complexes, create stability without having to have elites that guide them and so it explains how the natural world creates stability.

    Blairwatch: And were there other Game theories that didn't assume that people were naturally selfish?

    Adam Curtis: Well, the real problem with Game theory is that its fundamental assumption is that human beings are self interested. I mean they only did that to make their models work to begin with. People like Nash (who was one of the originators of all this) didn't actually assume that that's what people were like; he made that assumption in order to make his mathematical models work. What then shifted towards economists is they began to assume that really is how human beings are and actually in my second film I show that Nash has now recanted or believed that things are much more complicated than that.

    Blairwatch: Yes, I was fascinated by that.

    Adam Curtis: It was a shift towards that assumption, but the really interesting story, I always felt the key to all this is that when they tried to play on these games with the secretaries at the Rand corporation, really early on I think in something like the early 1950s, none of them behaved as one predicted, they just co-operated. And actually, there have been people subsequent to this who have done research in Game theory where you that if you play it over and over again (particular games) people very quickly learn that co-operation is by far the most efficient way of doing things.

    But no, the fundamental assumption that Game theory brought with it was that people are self interested. This is what I'm trying to show in these films; that behind our everyday world are certain basic assumptions about human beings and the fundamental one is that we are what economists call 'rational utility maximisers' and we pursue rationally what we want, and that's it.

    Blairwatch: When this was brought into economics, I think it's in the second film, you mention the perceived breakdown of the British public services. What would you attribute to this perceived breakdown other than the obvious financial stresses that were around at the time in the 70s?

    Adam Curtis: There was obviously an economic crisis in the 70s which was leading to chaos, but also within that failure of that post war project, people had no goals any longer in their bureaucracies and they began to pursue their own self interest. The question then is whether that then means that you then create a world totally based on self interest because you think that's what human beings are like or whether actually things are much more complicated than that but if you actually have an organisation where morale is low people do become rather self-interested because they haven't got any one else.
    See what Curtis is saying here is that in a free market people cannot cooperate with each other because they become too self interested.

  8. #7
    Quote Originally Posted by Son_of_Liberty90 View Post
    True but for Curtis to say that Hyek's ideas of Austrian economics were co-opted by game theory social scientists is misleading.

    Hayek and the austrian ideas were to say that rational self interest without coercion established good relations among people to benefit themselves and others. Curtis uses his narrative of Cold War social scientists adopting Austrain principles in the 1950's to develop game theory established from then on rational self interest turns us all into greedy, conniving, manipulative, and distrustful human beings.
    I always thought what made US great was an open recognition of this fact - people are greedy $#@!s. We were able to harness these desires for self betterment and advance the society as a whole. Are you a communist?

    That would, in effect, nullify any theory of libertarianism and anarcho capitalism discussed on RPF.
    I am not sure about that.

  9. #8
    Quote Originally Posted by timosman View Post
    How so? Humans have this tendency to take shortcuts. Eventually everything becomes just a game.
    That's not what game theory is.



  10. Remove this section of ads by registering.
  11. #9
    Quote Originally Posted by timosman View Post
    I always thought what made US great was an open recognition of this fact - people are greedy $#@!s. We were able to harness these desires for self betterment and advance the society as a whole. Are you a communist?


    Curtis leads you to believe that this is detrimental for society, and makes us want to cooperate less with each other because we become so distrustful and paranoid of each other's motives.

    The interview I posted makes the point more clear.

  12. #10
    Quote Originally Posted by Son_of_Liberty90 View Post
    Curtis leads you to believe that this is detrimental for society, and makes us want to cooperate less with each other because we become so distrustful and paranoid of each other's motives.
    All the while the government motives are always altruistic.

    The interview I posted makes the point more clear.
    Yes, it does. The guy is a total $#@!:

    the real problem with Game theory is that its fundamental assumption is that human beings are self interested
    Great job, comrade. That NAP thing was sure getting into the way.

  13. #11
    Quote Originally Posted by timosman View Post
    All the while the government motives are always altruistic.



    Yes, it does. The guy is a total $#@!:



    Great job, comrade. That NAP thing was sure getting into the way.
    Cool, I'm glad we're on the same page now

  14. #12
    One of my brothers is often talking about this guy and showed me a video or two.

    I never got a real good feeling from his view of things.

    Too bad Curtis tries to tie Hayek to greed.

    He seems to be either missing the most crucial information or deliberately misleading people.

  15. #13
    Quote Originally Posted by Dark_Horse_Rider View Post
    One of my brothers is often talking about this guy and showed me a video or two.

    I never got a real good feeling from his view of things.

    Too bad Curtis tries to tie Hayek to greed.

    He seems to be either missing the most crucial information or deliberately misleading people.
    He is just virtue signaling. He is also ass broke.



Similar Threads

  1. Adam Kokesh talks to Democratic Socialist
    By Todd in forum U.S. Political News
    Replies: 10
    Last Post: 03-07-2013, 10:47 PM
  2. Replies: 0
    Last Post: 03-11-2012, 03:11 PM
  3. Replies: 1
    Last Post: 05-25-2011, 10:00 AM
  4. Replies: 20
    Last Post: 07-25-2010, 11:40 PM
  5. The Socialist Utopia - a new documentary on Sweden released
    By GreenCardSeeker in forum U.S. Political News
    Replies: 11
    Last Post: 06-14-2009, 02:52 PM

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •