Watching it now...
good stuff!!
http://www.history.com/shows/america-the-story-of-us
YouTube - America the Story of Us: Trailer
I've watched the first and second episode, IMHO the series looks very promising.
Liberty, of course, has her price in blood, if we do not suppport her when she is in trouble.
Really? Wow I thought it would be a propaganda piece on how great government is.Originally Posted by TheBlackPeterSchiff
Watching it now...
good stuff!!
http://www.history.com/shows/america-the-story-of-us
YouTube - America the Story of Us: Trailer
Sorry, I thought it was horrible. Of course, I saw only one episode and it was on the Civil War. Basically, it was the typical glorification of Lincoln instead of questioning whether a man who was responsible for the death of 600,000 men is worthy of such deification.
Your thoughts are correct.Really? Wow I thought it would be a propaganda piece on how great government is.
I saw most of the first episode but I'd rather keep the politicians out of it.
I suspect this series has a pro-government perspective, and I notice that they suggest the Founders wanted democracy
I can only imagine how much they will glorify Woodrow Wilson and FDR.
I think the John Adams miniseries is far more inspiring than this.
This is government indoctrination school textbook stuff, but it's nicely produced.
Makes me want to barf in technicolor, at least.
I'm actually enjoying it, except for the parts where I scream and throw stuff at the screen.
ETA: Yeah, the John Adam miniseries was very good. I'm looking for one from the perspective of Jefferson, though. Anybody? Bueller?
Follow my blog at http://tirelessagorist.blogspot.com/
Current commentary from a libertarian/voluntaryist/agorist perspective.
Consistent Candidate - with Chainspell
2007
Ron Paul Landslide by Jake Kellen - Constitution Mix
The vision of the helpful and protective state is the most pervasive and counter-productive ideology in the world today.
Saw the first episode. It might be more enjoyable had they left out the in between commentary with all the politicians including: Obama, Rudy Giulaini etc...
The episode tonight is all about the cities. It's like there were no rural areas in America in the late part of the 19th century/early 20th century.
I think the scholars who write the Politically Incorrect guides would eyeroll at this.
"Your mother's dead, before long I'll be dead, and you...and your brother and your sister and all of her children, all of us dead, all of us..rotting in the ground. It's the family name that lives on. It's all that lives on. Not your personal glory, not your honor, but family." - Tywin Lannister
I turned the channel as soon as I saw it was sponsered by Bank of America.
I enjoy the production and quality of this show, but have problems with the history. First, the Civil War was glossed over and made all about slavery. It even says the Southern soldiers believe their cause "righteour," implying the poor farm boys were for slavery and not anti-tariff, pro states' rights, or just fighting for their homeland, which was mostly the case. And I do sympathize with Brown's Raid (which they discussed) and the plight of abolitionists like Thoreau, who were against the war and for seceding from the south to get away from slavery (which they didn't).
I had a problem with them glorifying Edison to and making it seem "his" light bulb revolutionized America. Several incandescent bulbs were around before Edison patented his. He was a scamster. Just like the movie camera was invented by a French guy before Edison patented it and that guy died. He also stole a bunch of Tesla's ideas. They also gloss over how scandelous the railroad and oil companies were.
Preventive war was an invention of Hitler. Frankly,I would not even listen to anyone seriously that talked about such a thing. ~ General Dwight D EisenhowerThose who know do not talk. Those who talk do not know. -Lao Tzu
I didnt catch the Civil War part.
But of course it's going to be told through the prism of how great the Federal govt is, but I thought it was still interesting.
I'm glad you enjoyed the propaganda.
The Peter Schiff Show - Production
Schiff for Senate 2010 Grassroots Team Leader
Former Campaign for Liberty Local Coordinator
Well, I haven't seen any of the episodes after no. 2, so....
and yes, it is a text book sanitized government approved "vision" of the past.
I actually learned something from the second show....
I wasn't home schooled, so forgive me for not knowing this before now...
The settlers had to deal with millions of squirrels raiding their crops. It was so bad, their was a bounty on the pelt of a squirrel. Marksmanship practice on squirrels really paid off: protected crops, meat on the table and bounty on the skin PLUS possibly recovering the lead for future shots....
No wonder the British lost! (and yes, I know it was more than marksmanship...)
Liberty, of course, has her price in blood, if we do not suppport her when she is in trouble.
Courtesy of early international bankers... Meyer Amschel Bauer
If not. Why not?From Wikipedia: "During the American Revolution, Great Britain hired mercenaries from Hesse, commonly known as Hessians, to fight the rebels in America. In fact, thousands of Hessians fought in the American Revolution and other conflicts as soldiers of fortune (though usually conscripted, the pay going to their Lord) on both sides."
I agree completely. I especially like how Lincoln ended slavery (single-handedly and everywhere!).This is government indoctrination school textbook stuff, but it's nicely produced.
Makes me want to barf in technicolor, at least.
I'm actually enjoying it, except for the parts where I scream and throw stuff at the screen.
ETA: Yeah, the John Adam miniseries was very good. I'm looking for one from the perspective of Jefferson, though. Anybody? Bueller?
Very well produced though...
I usually love shows like this but when I saw cameos from Giulaini and other MSM talking heads I refused to watch it.
It's not a bad show at all. Ive seen all the episodes and have enjoyed them all. You're never going to find any show or person who will agree with your perspective on everything when it comes to history. Just like truth, history is seen through the eyes of the beholder.
I agree though about having people like Guliani and company on there. Keep it to historians and not politicians.
The only way you can find the truth about history it to read and view stuff from all opinions and sides. I have Never read a book or watched a history show that was not biased.
The only way you can find the truth in history is by triangulation of all the different opinions.
Posting Permissions
Reply With Quote
Connect With Us