01-24-2025, 06:48 PM
Not necessarily. You can have a perfectly constructed SRY on an XY, and if the uterus is overwhelmed with estrogen during the period of sex differentiation, you'll end up with a female physiology. Most often, that's not the case - but it does occur. The individual probably won't be generating either large reproductive cells (the egg) or small reproductive cells (the sperm), but will probably have a female physiology. Again, really small numbers involved, but not zero - and not from genetics, but rather the mother's endocrine system.
That's why I think the system we've been using since before I was born is the best way to deal with it. The OB/GYN looking at the kid after it exits the chute and declaring male or female.
Biology, Psychology, Sociology and Physiology have all agreed for almost a half century that sex and gender are different. Sex is that immutable thing you're born with. Gender is a social construct that refers to the norms, roles, behaviors, and attitudes that a culture or society associates with being normal for a person of a given sex. I can live with that because I can see a need for that "social construct" spectrum; but I wish they had come up with a new term rather than repurposing "gender", which had always been a synonym for sex. But that's water over the dam at this point. Still - bathrooms, sports, prisons, verb conjugation (for languages like French and Spanish), pronouns and so forth should be based on sex (like they were when gender and sex meant the same thing) rather than this new thing they're now calling gender. My problem is not so much with the terms being different, but rather with what they mean by transitioning gender when gender is a social construct (as well as why would you need surgery, hormones or puberty blockers to transition a social construct).
== Edited ===
There is a effort being made by small groups within Physiology to include transgender physiology - which seems ridiculous to me. It makes as much sense as including silicon/saline bags to complete the physiology of women who have had breast implants, or appliances that compensate for loss of limbs or are designed to replace worn-out knees and hips.
Connect With Us