• Sentient Void

    by Published on 01-25-2014 12:42 AM

    First, what is 'the NAP':
    Quote Originally Posted by Wikipedia
    The non-aggression principle (NAP)... is a moral stance which asserts that aggression is inherently illegitimate. NAP and property rights are closely linked, since what aggression is depends on what a person's rights are. Aggression, for the purposes of NAP, is defined as the initiation or threatening of violence against a person or legitimately owned property of another. Specifically, any unsolicited actions of others that physically affect an individual’s property or person, no matter if the result of those actions is damaging, beneficial, or neutral to the owner, are considered violent or aggressive when they are against the owner's free will and interfere with his right to self-determination and the principle of self-ownership.
    Supporters of the NAP often appeal to it in order to argue for the immorality of theft, vandalism, assault, and fraud. In contrast to nonviolence, the non-aggression principle does not preclude violence used in self-defense or defense of others. Many supporters argue that NAP opposes such policies as victimless crime laws, taxation, and military drafts. NAP is the foundation of most present-day libertarian philosophies.
    Now, the NAP is the very beating heart of what libertarianism is and stands for, as a philosophy. It's not merely just for concepts of 'government' but really for general interaction with your fellow man. The whole idea is that the same moral principles good people apply to themselves and others are not exempted when it comes to government 'officials' of any sort - be it a police officer, soldier, representative, or the president himself. You can't give rights to others that you do not yourself have, even if you and a mob of 50 other people against 49 say otherwise.

    But, before (fellow) libertarians decide to 'revoke my libertarian card' after reading my critique - know that I am a firm advocate of the NAP. Basically, I think the best justice system will be built around the NAP and that a society that follows the NAP most consistently will be the most 'just', as well as the most prosperous and happy.

    That being said, far too many 'libertarians' et al say that the NAP is never to be violated, no matter what. They believe in a rigid adherence to the NAP - that it is some absolutist doctrine. I think this is a serious mistake and a failing of philosophy.

    Another caveat. Understand that while I provide an example to illustrate my point, the example itself is irrelevant. The point, is the logic. If our philosophy relies on consistent theories and tests based purely on a priori reasoning, we must be willing and able to take it to its logically implied extremes for rigorous testing. Bad ideas, taken to their logical conclusions, produce extremely bad results. That's how you detect bad ideas. Good ideas are just the opposite, and are tested in the same way. Moderation is only good for stopping us from taking bad ideas too far. Also, we cannot remain intellectually honest and claim a priorism is the most important path to truth and knowledge, yet only cherry pick when we want to use it and when we don't.

    So here we are. The NAP must be logically tested at its extremes just the same as we would (and should) concepts of corporatism, socialism, communism, and whatever other flavor of -ism you can come up with. We could really use any logical extreme, even ones we'd imagine are virtually or completely impossible to ever take place, and they would still be valid. For the sake of making the NAP zealots happy, we'll try to use a fairly realistic, albeit simple, thought-experiment.

    Let's say it was 3:00 AM and you had to drive your daughter home (from wherever, for whatever reason). Suddenly, you realize that you (the imperfect human that you are) made a mistake and forgot her medicine (whatever it is), or that she ran out, or it was lost, or some other situation. She gets horribly sick and is potentially near death within five or ten minutes, unless you get medicine very quickly. You just drove by a closed pharmacy. What do you do?

    Continued in Sentient Void's blog...
  • Top Activist Efforts

  • Activism News & Discussion

  • Ron Paul & Rand Paul: News & Discussion

    Brian4Liberty

    Tucker Carlson Interviews Ron Paul

    Thread Starter: Brian4Liberty

    1762644273814532371 https://twitter.com/RonPaul/status/1762644273814532371

    Last Post By: Occam's Banana Today, 09:09 AM Go to last post
    Brian4Liberty

    'Hell No, We Won't Go!' - Most Americans Would Not Serve If War Broke Out

    Thread Starter: Brian4Liberty

    'Hell No, We Won't Go!' - Most Americans Would Not Serve If War Broke Out v4jhefw

    Last Post By: acptulsa Today, 08:58 AM Go to last post
  • General News & Politics

    PAF

    Land of the Free?

    Thread Starter: PAF

    By Llewellyn H. Rockwell, Jr. March 29, 2024 Thanks, Robert Roche. 1773349674495168918 https://www.lewrockwell.com/political-theatre/land-of-the-free/

    Last Post By: Anti Federalist Today, 08:56 AM Go to last post
    CaptUSA

    Francis Scott Key Bridge Collapse

    Thread Starter: CaptUSA

    Cargo ship hits bridge in Baltimore causing bridge to collapse with several cars still on the bridge. Dramatic footage of collapse at link: https://www.the-sun.com/news/10887766/maryland-francis-scott-key-bridge-collapses/

    Last Post By: sparebulb Today, 07:50 AM Go to last post
    jct74

    60 Minutes claims evidence of foreign adversary behind Havana Syndrome attacks

    Thread Starter: jct74

    1773412210305270180 https://twitter.com/60Minutes/status/1773412210305270180

    Last Post By: sparebulb Today, 07:34 AM Go to last post
    Anti Federalist

    NYC - The chokehold death of Jordan Neely

    Thread Starter: Anti Federalist

    Oh boy... Jordan Neely was a homeless man and "street performer". Cops say he 44 prior arrests for assault, disorderly conduct, and fare evasion. Witnesses say he was making threats and harassing passengers. A 24 year old former marine subdued him with a full body chokehold, which ultimately killed him.

    Last Post By: Valli6 Today, 07:23 AM Go to last post
    Matt Collins

    Assange could serve no more jail time if he pleads guilty:

    Thread Starter: Matt Collins

    https://www.wsj.com/world/europe/julian-assange-justice-department-exploring-guilty-plea-to-end-14-year-legal-drama-09c6ff83

    Last Post By: PAF Today, 07:14 AM Go to last post
    Occam's Banana

    RFK Jr.'s 2024 POTUS campaign

    Thread Starter: Occam's Banana

    Robert F Kennedy Jr to challenge Biden for White House https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-65197673 Chloe Kim (05 April 2023) Robert F Kennedy Jr has filed election paperwork to run for US president in 2024 as a Democrat. The 69-year-old is the son of assassinated Senator Robert F Kennedy and nephew of President John F Kennedy. The environmental lawyer's campaign treasurer, John E...

    Last Post By: acptulsa Today, 06:29 AM Go to last post
    PAF

    Trump Promises a “100% Tariff” on Cars Made Outside the US

    Thread Starter: PAF

    During Biden’s term in office —-> ban TicTok Trump, if elected again —-> effectively bans free trade on automobiles. Ban ban ban. “When America can’t/won’t compete, it conquers.” “When goods don’t cross borders, Soldiers will.”

    Last Post By: Swordsmyth Today, 06:18 AM Go to last post
    Occam's Banana

    News From the Select Subcommittee on the Weaponization of the Federal Government

    Thread Starter: Occam's Banana

    This thread is for any news, updates, and other items concerning or related to the activities, hearings, etc. of the U.S. House Committee on the Judiciary Select Subcommittee on the Weaponization of the Federal Government (i.e., the so-called "New Church Committee"). The first hearings were scheduled for today (Thursday, 09 February 2023). Please post such items (or links to threads about such...

    Last Post By: acptulsa Today, 05:40 AM Go to last post
    unknown

    Feds raid P. Diddy's homes. He flees the country.

    Thread Starter: unknown

    . Sean ‘Diddy' Combs' Holmby Hills mansion raided by Feds.

    Last Post By: susano Today, 03:29 AM Go to last post
    Anti Federalist

    Oregonians support ending drug decriminalization

    Thread Starter: Anti Federalist

    Oregonians support ending drug decriminalization amid rising overdoses, 'radicalized social justice movement' https://www.foxnews.com/media/oregonians-support-ending-drug-decriminalization-rising-overdoses-radicalized-social-justice-movement September 1, 2023 12:00pm EDT A majority of Oregon voters believe its law to decriminalize drugs should be repealed, according to an August poll. ...

    Last Post By: susano Today, 02:37 AM Go to last post
  • Gold Price Chart

    [Most Recent Quotes from www.kitco.com]
  • Silver Price Chart

  • Economics News & Discussion

    Matt Collins

    CPI jumps 5% in May of 2021, fastest since 2008

    Thread Starter: Matt Collins

    If they are admitting a 5% jump, the true number is probably more like 15%-20% https://www.nytimes.com/2021/06/10/business/consumer-price-index-may-2021.html

    Last Post By: ClaytonB 03-26-2024, 10:20 AM Go to last post
  • Bitcoin Price Chart

  • Living Free and Healthy

  • Education & Thought Power

    Madison320

    Thought experiment to show why protectionism damages the economy

    Thread Starter: Madison320

    I've heard a lot of people say the problem with free trade is that it only works when both countries are allowing trade. That's wrong. For example even if China sells to us but doesn't allow us to sell to them, it still benefits us (and hurts China). Suppose in the US, a strange new volcano started spewing perfectly formed free high grade steel. Should the US ban the free steel because it...

    Last Post By: CaptUSA Today, 06:57 AM Go to last post
    Occam's Banana

    Does libertarianism require support for open borders?

    Thread Starter: Occam's Banana

    https://twitter.com/ComicDaveSmith/status/1761418253778436478 Does Libertarianism Require Support for Open Borders? https://odysee.com/@mises:1/does-libertarianism-require-support-for:2 {Mises Media | 23 February 2024} Dave Smith makes the Rothbardian/Hoppean case for government restriction on immigration, arguing that it's a second-best solution given the undeniable fact of government...

    Last Post By: Swordsmyth Today, 01:16 AM Go to last post
    A Son of Liberty

    Dave Smith / Part of the Problem

    Thread Starter: A Son of Liberty

    I'll endeavor to post each episode of Dave Smith's, Part of the Problem podcast here, going forward. Feel free to discuss/opine.

    Last Post By: Occam's Banana Yesterday, 03:12 PM Go to last post
    Occam's Banana

    Ayn Rand & the Austrian economists

    Thread Starter: Occam's Banana

    Ayn Rand and the Austrian Economists | Edward W. Younkins https://odysee.com/@mises:1/ayn-rand-and-the-austrian-economists:a {Mises Media | 23 March 2024} Henry Hazlitt Memorial Lecture. Sponsored by Shone and Brae Sadler. Recorded at the Austrian Economics Research Conference, 22 March 2024, in Auburn, Alabama. Includes an introduction by Joseph T. Salerno. Chapters:

    Last Post By: Occam's Banana 03-26-2024, 07:34 PM Go to last post
    PAF

    Squatters’ Rights: What to Know as a Landlord & Laws per State

    Thread Starter: PAF

    Published February 8, 2024 By: Jealie Dacanay As a landlord, understanding squatters’ rights and regulations is crucial to protecting your property and ensuring a smooth tenancy. Squatting is an often misunderstood property ownership aspect, but in this guide, I provide a roadmap for landlords to safeguard their investments. I delve into why squatters’ rights exist, when they apply,...

    Last Post By: Occam's Banana 03-26-2024, 07:29 PM Go to last post
    acptulsa

    Politics Is...

    Thread Starter: acptulsa

    Last Post By: ClaytonB 03-25-2024, 08:34 PM Go to last post
  • Follow us on Twitter! Subscribe to our top news RSS Feed!