• Statistics: Achilles' Heel of Government

    Statistics: Achilles' Heel of Government

    By Murray N. Rothbard

    Mises.org


    April 1, 2016


    Ours is truly an Age of Statistics. In a country and an era that worships statistical data as super “scientific,” as offering us the keys to all knowledge, a vast supply of data of all shapes and sizes pours forth upon us. Mostly, it pours forth from the government. While private agencies and trade associations do gather and issue some statistics, they are limited to specific wants of specific industries. The vast bulk of statistics is gathered and disseminated by government. The overall statistics of the economy, the popular “gross national product” data that permits every economist to be a soothsayer of business conditions, come from government. Furthermore, many statistics are by-products of other governmental activities: from the Internal Revenue bureau come tax data, from unemployment insurance departments, come estimates of the unemployed, from customs offices come data on foreign trade, from the Federal Reserve flow statistics on banking, and so on. And as new statistical techniques are developed, new divisions of government departments are created to refine and use them.

    The burgeoning of government statistics offers several obvious evils to the libertarian. In the first place, it is clear that too many resources are being channeled into statistics-gathering and statistics-production. Given a wholly free market, the amount of labor, land, and capital resources devoted to statistics would dwindle to a small fraction of the present total. It has been estimated that the federal government alone spends over $48,000,000 on statistics and that statistical work employs the services of over 10,000 full-time civilian employees of the government.1

    The Hidden Costs of Coerced Reporting

    Second, the great bulk of statistics is gathered by government coercion. This not only means that they are products of unwelcome activities; it also means that the true cost of these statistics to the American public is much greater than the mere amount of tax money spent by the government agencies. Private industry, and the private consumer must bear the burdensome costs of record keeping, filing, and the like, that these statistics demand. Not only that; these fixed costs impose a relatively great burden on small business firms, which are ill-equipped to handle the mountains of red tape. Hence, these seemingly innocent statistics cripple small business enterprise and help to rigidify the American business system. A Hoover Commission task force found, for example, that:

    No one knows how much it costs American industry to compile the statistics that the Government demands. The chemical industry alone reports that each year it spends $8,850,000 to supply statistical reports demanded by three departments of the Government. The utility industry spends $32,000,000 a year in preparing reports for Government agencies …All industrial users of peanuts must report their consumption to the Department of Agriculture. … Upon the intervention of the Task Force, the Department of Agriculture agreed that henceforth only those that consume more than ten thousand pounds a year need report …
    Many employees of private industry are occupied with the collection of Government statistics. This is especially burdensome to small businesses. A small hardware store owner in Ohio estimated that 29 per cent of his time is absorbed in filling out such reports. Not infrequently people dealing with the Government have to keep several sets of books to fit the diverse and dissimilar requirements of Federal agencies.2

    Other Objections

    But there are other important, and not so obvious, reasons for the libertarian to regard government statistics with dismay. Not only do statistics gathering and producing go beyond the governmental function of defense of persons and property; not only are economic resources wasted and misallocated, and the taxpayers, industry, small business and the consumer burdened. But, furthermore, statistics are, in a crucial sense, critical to all interventionist and socialist activities of government. The individual consumer, in his daily rounds, has little need of statistics; through advertising, through the information of friends, and through his own experience, he finds out what is going on in the markets around him. The same is true of the business firm. The businessman must also size up his particular market, determine the prices he has to pay for what he buys and charge for what he sells, engage in cost accounting to estimate his costs, and so on. But none of this activity is really dependent upon the omnium gatherum of statistical facts about the economy ingested by the federal government. The businessman, like the consumer, knows and learns about his particular market through his daily experience.

    Bureaucrats as well as statist reformers, however, are in a completely different state of affairs. They are decidedly outside the market. Therefore, in order to get “into” the situation that they are trying to plan and reform, they must obtain knowledge that is not personal, day-to-day experience; the only form that such knowledge can take is statistics.3 Statistics are the eyes and ears of the bureaucrat, the politician, the socialistic reformer. Only by statistics can they know, or at least have any idea about, what is going on in the economy.4Only by statistics can they find out how many old people have rickets, or how many young people have cavities, or how many Eskimos have defective sealskins—and therefore only by statistics can these interventionists discover who “needs” what throughout the economy, and how much federal money should be channeled in what directions. And certainly, only by statistics can the federal government make even a fitful attempt to plan, regulate, control, or reform various industries—or impose central planning and socialization on the entire economic system. If the government received no railroad statistics, for example, how in the world could it even start to regulate railroad rates, finances, and other affairs? How could the government impose price controls if it didn’t even know what goods have been sold on the market, and what prices were prevailing? Statistics, to repeat, are the eyes and ears of the interventionists: of the intellectual reformer, the politician, and the government bureaucrat. Cut off those eyes and ears, destroy those crucial guidelines to knowledge, and the whole threat of government intervention is almost completely eliminated.5

    Without Statistics Bureaucracy Would Wither Away

    It is true, of course, that even deprived of all statistical knowledge of the nation’s affairs, the government could still try to intervene, to tax and subsidize, to regulate and control. It could try to subsidize the aged even without having the slightest idea of how many aged there are and where they are located; it could try to regulate an industry without even knowing how many firms there are or any other basic facts of the industry; it could try to regulate the business cycle without even knowing whether prices or business activity are going up or down. It could try, but it would not get very far. The utter chaos would be too patent and too evident even for the bureaucracy, and certainly for the citizens. And this is especially true since one of the major reasons put forth for government intervention is that it “corrects” the market, and makes the market and the economy more rational. Obviously, if the government was deprived of all knowledge whatever of economic affairs, there could not even be a pretense of rationality in government intervention. Surely, the absence of statistics would absolutely and immediately wreck any attempt at socialistic planning. It is difficult to see what, for example, the central planners at the Kremlin could do to plan the lives of Soviet citizens if the planners were deprived of all information, of all statistical data, about these citizens. The government would not even know to whom to give orders, much less how to try to plan an intricate economy.

    Thus, in all the host of measures that have been proposed over the years to check and limit government or to repeal its interventions, the simple and unspectacular abolition of government statistics would probably be the most thorough and most effective. Statistics, so vital to statism, its namesake, is also the State’s Achilles’ heel.

    [Originally printed in from Essays on Liberty (Irvington-on-Hudson, N.Y.: Foundation for Economic Education, 1961), Available in The Rothbard Reader]


    • 1.Cf. Neil Macneil and Harold W. Metz, The Hoover Report, 1953–1955 (New York: Macmillan, 1956), pp. 90–91; Commission on Organization of the Executive Branch of the Government, Task Force Report on Paperwork Management (Washington, DC: June 1955); and idem, Report on Budgeting and Accounting (Washington, DC: February 1949).
    • 2.Macneil and Metz, The Hoover Report, pp. 90–91.
    • 3.On the deficiencies of statistics as compared to the personal knowledge of all participants utilized on the free market, see the illuminating discussion in F.A. Hayek, Individualism and the Economic Order (Chicago: University Press, 1948), chap. 4. Also, see Geoffrey Dobbs, On Planning the Earth (Liverpool: K.R.P. Pubs., 1951), pp. 77–86.
    • 4.As early as 1863, Samuel B. Ruggles, American Delegate to the International Statistical Congress in Berlin, declared: “Statistics are the very eyes of the statesmen, enabling him to survey and scan with the clear and comprehensive vision the whole structure and economy of the body politic.” For more on the interrelation of statistics—and statisticians—and the government, see Murray N. Rothbard, “The Politics of Political Economists: Comment,” Quarterly Journal of Economics (November 1960): 659–65. Also, see Dobbs,On Planning the Earth.
    • 5.Macneil and Metz, Reports on Budgeting and Accounting, pp. 91–92:Government policy depends upon much detailed knowledge about the Nation’s employment, production, and purchasing power.



    The formulation of legislation and administrative progress. … Supervision … regulation … and control … must be guided by knowledge of a wide range of relevant facts. Today as never before, statistical data play a major role in the supervision of Government activities. Administrators not only make plans in the light of known facts in their field of interest, but also, they must have reports on the actual progress achieved in accomplishing their goals.

    Note: The views expressed on Mises.org are not necessarily those of the Mises Institute.
    The Best of Murray N. Rothbard

    Murray N. Rothbard (1926–1995) was dean of the Austrian School, founder of modern libertarianism, and academic vice president of the Mises Institute. He was also editor – with Lew Rockwell – of The Rothbard-Rockwell Report, and appointed Lew as his literary executor. See his books.




    https://www.lewrockwell.com/2016/04/...el-government/


    Sign up for a free account to add your comment!


    Comments 11 Comments
    1. Zippyjuan's Avatar
      Zippyjuan -
      Interesting. An article using statistics trying to say we don't need statistics.
    1. Ronin Truth's Avatar
      Ronin Truth -
      Quote Originally Posted by Zippyjuan View Post
      Interesting. An article using statistics trying to say we don't need statistics.
      We don't need any government busy body, none of their damned business statistics.
    1. Zippyjuan's Avatar
      Zippyjuan -
      Without statistics how do you know if you have a good or bad government? If they don't keep track of and report taxes and spending how do you know they are doing too much of it? Did they spend too much on that program? We don't know. "We don't need to know how much government spends or what they spend it on or how much in debt they are- we don't need statistics!"

      Statistics are just numbers. They can have good and bad uses. They can show good things and bad things. To say we don't need them is silly.

      I do note that one of the points seemed to be more the costs of collecting data but there is also a cost to not having data- leading to mis-allocation of resources and increased waste. Better data helps you make better decisions.
    1. Ronin Truth's Avatar
      Ronin Truth -
      Quote Originally Posted by Zippyjuan View Post
      Without statistics how do you know if you have a good or bad government? If they don't keep track of and report taxes and spending how do you know they are doing too much of it? Did they spend too much on that program? We don't know. "We don't need to know how much government spends or what they spend it on or how much in debt they are- we don't need statistics!"

      Statistics are just numbers. They can have good and bad uses. They can show good things and bad things. To say we don't need them is silly.

      I do note that one of the points seemed to be more the costs of collecting data but there is also a cost to not having data- leading to mis-allocation of resources and increased waste. Better data helps you make better decisions.
      It's always just easy (and correct) to figure you have a bad government. It's really just a no-brainer on the basis of the last 7,000 years of human history.
    1. Zippyjuan's Avatar
      Zippyjuan -
      That usually works!
    1. idiom's Avatar
      idiom -
      The internet and most of the modern economy runs on statistics.

      Just because it has the word statist in it Jeez.
    1. Ronin Truth's Avatar
      Ronin Truth -
      Quote Originally Posted by idiom View Post
      The internet and most of the modern economy runs on statistics.

      Just because it has the word statist in it Jeez.
      Murray was only griping about the government stats data collections charged to the taxpayers.
    1. idiom's Avatar
      idiom -
      Quote Originally Posted by Ronin Truth View Post
      Murray was only griping about the government stats data collections charged to the taxpayers.
      Then he would love how much more cheaply the government can now buy much more granular and reliable data on the entire populace.
    1. Natural Citizen's Avatar
      Natural Citizen -
      Quote Originally Posted by Zippyjuan View Post
      Without statistics how do you know if you have a good or bad government? If they don't keep track of and report taxes and spending how do you know they are doing too much of it? Did they spend too much on that program? We don't know. "We don't need to know how much government spends or what they spend it on or how much in debt they are- we don't need statistics!"

      Statistics are just numbers. They can have good and bad uses. They can show good things and bad things. To say we don't need them is silly.

      I do note that one of the points seemed to be more the costs of collecting data but there is also a cost to not having data- leading to mis-allocation of resources and increased waste. Better data helps you make better decisions.
      There exists a tendency to misunderstand the nature of statistics when focused on statistics themselves. It's interesting to read/listen to debate where "statistics" guide debate/discussion.
    1. Lucille's Avatar
      Lucille -
    1. Ronin Truth's Avatar
      Ronin Truth -
      Quote Originally Posted by Lucille View Post
      +Rep!


    Sign up for a free account to add your comment!





    Continue / discuss in the forums Read More

  • Activism News & Discussion

    GunnyFreedom

    Glen Bradley for NC House 7 needs your help

    Thread Starter: GunnyFreedom

    Hello everyone! As most of you know, I am running for NC State House out of the 7th District. What many of you may not know, is on the last day of filing, I received a primary challenge. We did not actually expect a primary challenger, but we do have one. My opponent is wealthy and largely self-funding, but her funds are listed as loans and she will be getting every penny of that back...

    Last Post By: Origanalist Today, 11:06 PM Go to last post
    ZakCarter

    What's up with Ben Swann lately? (UPDATE: website & social media back up!))

    Thread Starter: ZakCarter

    So yes, Ben Swann and the Truth in Media team were on a serious roll towards the end of 2015, and then we made this mini-documentary - https://vimeo.com/153178203 and I really thought that would be the last one with my name in the credits under distribution, because we were going to Hollywood baby! Everything was going right, we had 3 TV networks lined up to broadcast that video, and a...

    Last Post By: ZakCarter Today, 02:25 PM Go to last post
    ProudAmericanFirst

    30 Second Activist Action Needed (H.R. 4760)

    Thread Starter: ProudAmericanFirst

    Please take 30 seconds to contact your Congress person and urge to vote NO on H.R. 4760 H.R. 4760 - Securing America’s Future Act of 2018 - is actually a bill to Require National Biometric ID for ALL Americans. This bill was introduced by Rep Bob Goodlatte under the auspices of providing a solution for current beneficiaries of the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) program. So...

    Last Post By: not.your.average.joe Yesterday, 02:08 PM Go to last post
    Bryan

    MSM scorecard on spin: blowback issue

    Thread Starter: Bryan

    It seems that most all the main stream media is spinning the Ron and Rudy exchange as a great victory for Rudy and are trying to paint the "Ron hates America" label due to some audience applause. A simple analysis of the issue however shows that Ron Paul was factually correct as supported by the CIA and the 9/11 Commission Report. I thought it would be useful to see who in the MSM landed...

    Last Post By: timosman 04-23-2018, 06:07 PM Go to last post
    LibertasPraesidium

    Libertarians are Evil????

    Thread Starter: LibertasPraesidium

    http://gawker.com/5840024/ron-pauls-campaign-manager-died-of-pneumonia-penniless-and-uninsured The comments on this page make a great many assumptions about libertarians and the heartless bunch that no longer want to be burdened by taking care of those who refuse to take care of themselves. I am confused as to how many of the comments on their even make sense, let alone believe that it is the...

    Last Post By: H_H 04-23-2018, 08:18 AM Go to last post
  • Ron Paul & Rand Paul: News & Discussion

    Matt Collins

    Rand sells out and flip-flops on Pompeo nomination

    Thread Starter: Matt Collins

    What the hell? :confused: https://www.cnn.com/2018/04/23/politics/pompeo-committee-vote-separate/index.html https://twitter.com/RandPaul/status/988523293396406272 https://twitter.com/RandPaul/status/988523697886711808

    Last Post By: phill4paul Today, 10:42 PM Go to last post
    timosman

    How to appear decisive and confident

    Thread Starter: timosman

    There is an upcoming nomination hearing and a week before it POTUS asks you to meet with the candidate. Your meeting is great but you don't talk about anything of importance. During the hearing the candidate flabs the only important question you have for him. You make up a story where after the questioning you talk to the candidate again and this time he nails the question and you vote yes....

    Last Post By: nikcers Today, 08:21 PM Go to last post
    EBounding

    Rand Opposes Pompeo and Haspel

    Thread Starter: EBounding

    973937563068223488 --- Rand Paul: Why I’ll Fight Gina Haspel and Mike Pompeo Nominations

    Last Post By: Swordsmyth Yesterday, 06:16 PM Go to last post
    Brian4Liberty

    Another False Flag - Will Trump Escalate In Syria?

    Thread Starter: Brian4Liberty

    Another False Flag - Will Trump Escalate In Syria?

    Last Post By: bunklocoempire Yesterday, 11:10 AM Go to last post
  • General News & Politics

    AuH20

    Kanye West Hospitalized After Controversial Comments

    Thread Starter: AuH20

    Did he rebel against his handlers? https://www.yahoo.com/music/report-kanye-west-hospitalized-following-013456457.html

    Last Post By: The Rebel Poet Today, 10:14 PM Go to last post
    Swordsmyth

    Pelosi defends party intervention in Democratic primaries

    Thread Starter: Swordsmyth

    House Democratic Leader Nancy Pelosi (Calif.) defended her party’s electoral operation on Thursday, after a candidate in a contested Colorado primary released audio tape of Democratic Whip Steny Hoyer (Md.) urging him to quit the race. “I don’t know that a person can tape a person without the person’s consent and then release it to the press,” Pelosi told reporters at her weekly news...

    Last Post By: Swordsmyth Today, 10:12 PM Go to last post
    phill4paul

    A soldier just got authorization to wear a beard because of his Norse pagan faith

    Thread Starter: phill4paul

    They didn't have this choice back in my day when I was 18, in the Navy, and a Norse pagan. Hell, you can even get a Thor's hammer on your gravemarker... https://www.armytimes.com/news/your-army/2018/04/25/this-soldier-just-got-authorization-to-wear-a-beard-because-of-his-norse-pagan-faith/

    Last Post By: Swordsmyth Today, 09:25 PM Go to last post
    Swordsmyth

    Trump: "We're Coming Out Of Syria Very Soon; Others Can Take Care Of It Now"

    Thread Starter: Swordsmyth

    President Donald Trump made a surprise announcement on Thursday afternoon, stating during a speech in Richfield, Ohio dedicated to Trump's infrastructure week, that US forces will be withdrawing from Syria, citing the defeat of ISIS and the need to defend US borders and rebuild crumbling infrastructure: "We're coming out of Syria very soon. Let the other people take care of it now." Others...

    Last Post By: goldenequity Today, 09:17 PM Go to last post
    timosman

    Maxine Waters claims '70 percent of women' want Trump impeached

    Thread Starter: timosman

    Last Post By: oyarde Today, 08:53 PM Go to last post
    ZakCarter

    Ben Swann: : Are Gun Confiscation Laws Trampling Your Civil Liberties?

    Thread Starter: ZakCarter

    "A candidate for sheriff in North Carolina has said he would confiscate guns in his county by taking them from the “cold, dead hands” of the people he is supposed to protect. Now, he says he was only joking. Joking or not, the attitude of gun confiscation is raising concern about the power of law enforcement in this country. And are newly enacted gun confiscation laws violating due process and...

    Last Post By: pcosmar Today, 07:30 PM Go to last post
    Brian4Liberty

    Syria and the Revolt of the ‘Deplorables’

    Thread Starter: Brian4Liberty

    Syria and the Revolt of the ‘Deplorables’ Trump bombs his base by Justin Raimondo - April 16, 2018

    Last Post By: r3volution 3.0 Today, 07:15 PM Go to last post
    enhanced_deficit

    Controversial Israeli minister and 'racist' Lieberman arrives in D.C. to take on Iran Deal

    Thread Starter: enhanced_deficit

    Minister of our closest ally in the world and only NRD democracy in mideast and a darling of extreme wing of zionism is in US to talk Iran nuke deal while all the MSM news focus is on French Prez visit. He had also been labeled 'racist' by liberal anti-occupation Israeli groups. Be interestuing to see how ZOA/Jarvanka/John Bolton respond to this visit:

    Last Post By: enhanced_deficit Today, 05:08 PM Go to last post
    euphemia

    [17 Dead] Numerous Fatalities at Douglas High School, Parkland, FL

    Thread Starter: euphemia

    Sad, sad, sad. A gunman opened fire at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High school in Parkland, Fla., on Wednesday, officials there said. According to local news reports, at least 20 people were injured. The Broward County Sheriff’s Office said the shooting suspect, who fled the scene, has been taken into custody. Follow below for the latest updates. Link1 At least 20 students were feared hurt...

    Last Post By: timosman Today, 05:00 PM Go to last post
    enhanced_deficit

    Alleged payment to porn star was illegal donation to Trump campaign, watchdog says

    Thread Starter: enhanced_deficit

    Is this Comey/Mueller supporters covertly pushing this or this is just some media watchdog's investigative journalism work? As if Trump-Kushner team needed another hushmoney gate scandal on the heels of growing list of Israel-Flynn gate, Bannon claimed Kushner money laundering gate, Peggy Peterson-Michael Cohen gate scandals etc. Alleged payment to porn...

    Last Post By: enhanced_deficit Today, 04:53 PM Go to last post
  • Gold Chart

    [Most Recent Quotes from www.kitco.com]
  • Silver Chart

  • Economics News & Discussion

    DamianTV

    Blain: "Millennials Aren’t Buying Cars Or Homes Because They Are Indentured Slaves" (UK)

    Thread Starter: DamianTV

    https://www.zerohedge.com/news/2018-04-26/blain-millennials-arent-buying-cars-or-homes-because-they-are-indentured-slaves The economy is faltering because the stupid selfish middle class isnt spending enough! The party must go on forever! What could possibly go wrong?

    Last Post By: thoughtomator Today, 06:28 PM Go to last post
    timosman

    Indians flock to America's 'golden visa' as H-1B route closes

    Thread Starter: timosman

    http://money.cnn.com/2018/04/25/news/economy/immigration-h1b-eb5-investor-visa-india/index.html

    Last Post By: timosman Today, 05:05 PM Go to last post
    ZakCarter

    Goldman Sachs Questions Whether Curing Disease is Economically Sustainable

    Thread Starter: ZakCarter

    Can cryptocurrencies kill the banks already?! "Goldman Sachs, in an April report to clients, addressed an ethical conundrum facing pharmaceutical and biotechnology companies in regard to futuristic cures based on cutting edge gene therapy: “one shot cures,” rather than the model of continuous treatment, could be difficult for some “medicine developers looking for a sustained cash flow.” In...

    Last Post By: Swordsmyth 04-24-2018, 06:57 PM Go to last post
    anaconda

    Bitcoin Cracks $5000

    Thread Starter: anaconda

    https://www.forbes.com/sites/cbovaird/2017/09/01/bitcoin-price-tops-5000-as-cryptocurrencies-march-higher/#6d8dc42a5a8e

    Last Post By: dannno 04-24-2018, 02:38 PM Go to last post
    ChooseLiberty

    Market Crash Looming

    Thread Starter: ChooseLiberty

    Wuh Woh It's October, time for a crash. It's not that easy is it? Is it? http://www.safehaven.com/article-14697.htm

    Last Post By: oyarde 04-24-2018, 11:26 AM Go to last post
  • Bitcoin Chart

  • Living Free and Healthy

    enhanced_deficit

    Coffee to come with cancer warning in California

    Thread Starter: enhanced_deficit

    So confusing, up till few months ago coffee was good for health: Coffee requires cancer warning, California judge rules by Associated Press / Mar.30.2018 LOS ANGELES — Scientists haven't rendered a verdict on whether coffee is good or bad for you but a California judge has. He says coffee sellers in the state should have to post cancer warnings. The culprit is a chemical produced...

    Last Post By: donnay Today, 08:53 AM Go to last post
    Swordsmyth

    Certain common medications tied to 30% higher dementia risk

    Thread Starter: Swordsmyth

    Many older adults know that long-term use of certain medications can negatively affect cognition and increase one's risk of dementia. But a new study suggests that some classes of anticholinergic drugs -- particularly those used to treat depression, Parkinson's and urinary incontinence -- carry a higher risk than others. Anticholinergic drugs function by blocking the effects of...

    Last Post By: Firestarter Today, 03:29 AM Go to last post
    Schifference

    Going to be Semi- off grid for a couple of months

    Thread Starter: Schifference

    Pulling an old Jayco Camping trailer to South Carolina where I purchased a dilapidated old house that needs lots of work. I plan on living in camper a couple of months this fall and a couple more in the spring. Refrigeration will be small. I don't want to spend lots of time or energy on food. I decided to purchase a pressure cooker canner and some canning jars. I am going to can meat, soup,...

    Last Post By: Schifference Yesterday, 05:09 AM Go to last post
    donnay

    Report: NYT Pushes CDC Flu Shot Narrative, Ignores Neurotoxin Damage

    Thread Starter: donnay

    https://worldmercuryproject.org/news/the-new-york-times-vs-the-science-on-the-flu-shot/

    Last Post By: Danke 04-24-2018, 12:03 PM Go to last post
    Danke

    It is gonna be a cold winter.

    Thread Starter: Danke

    This fall the Indians on a remote reservation asked their new Chief Oyarde if the coming winter was going to be cold or mild. Since he was a chief in a modern society, he’d never learned the old tribal secrets. He couldn’t look at the sky to predict what the winter was going to be like. "It's going to be a very cold winter." So just to be on the safe side, Oyarde told his tribe that the...

    Last Post By: oyarde 04-24-2018, 11:09 AM Go to last post
  • Education & Thought Power

    Intoxiklown

    Anarch, State and Utopia by Robert Nozick

    Thread Starter: Intoxiklown

    Wanted to post this as I had never heard of this book before nor seen it mentioned here on the forums that I recall. A friend suggested I check it out following a discussion about politics and realizing my views were grounded in libertarian philosophy. I'm about half way through it but so far it's really good (good enough that I took a break to mention it here). But apparently this book had a lot...

    Last Post By: r3volution 3.0 Today, 07:50 PM Go to last post
    timosman

    Is the amount of payola increasing?

    Thread Starter: timosman

    Let's look at the 2000-20018 period. Do we have now more payola or less payola?

    Last Post By: RonZeplin Today, 07:47 PM Go to last post
    Firestarter

    List of admitted false flag attacks

    Thread Starter: Firestarter

    I’ve found a long list of false flag attacks that have been “admitted” by the government that carried them out: http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2017-03-07/ever-growing-list-admitted-false-flag-attacks (1) Mukden or Manchurian Incident - Japanese troops set off an explosion on a train track (1931), and blamed it on China in order to justify an invasion of Manchuria. (2) Attacks on Germans –...

    Last Post By: Firestarter Today, 10:40 AM Go to last post
    Firestarter

    Drugs profits for Oil wars

    Thread Starter: Firestarter

    I found an interesting book that describes the “War by drugs”- Peter Dale Scott “Drugs, Oil, and War: The United States in Afghanistan, Columbia, and Indochina” (2003): https://ourrebellion.files.wordpress.com/2010/09/book-the-us-in-afghanistan-colombia-and-indo-china.pdf It is 16 GB to download (I’ve saved it as a text document at 0.5 GB)… My very short summary of the Peter Dale Scott book is...

    Last Post By: Firestarter Today, 10:38 AM Go to last post
  • Follow us on Twitter! Like us on Facebook! Subscribe to our top news RSS Feed! New! Subscribe to us on YouTube!