PDA

View Full Version : US Christian who refuses to pay taxes until abortion is defunded has first big win in court




PAF
02-20-2019, 08:15 AM
Older news but great news. I didn't find it here but apologies if it was already posted.


Wed Apr 18, 2018


COLUMBIA CITY, Oregon, April 18, 2018 (LifeSiteNews) – Like 60% of Americans, Michael Bowman opposes taxpayer funding of abortion. Unlike most Americans, he is currently squaring off against the Internal Revenue Service to avoid doing so.

Bowman is a 53-year-old Christian and contract engineer in Columbia City, Oregon. He has refused to file a tax return or pay taxes since 1999, The Oregonian reports, citing the federal government’s funding of the abortion industry.

"I'm not a tax protester. I love my country,” he told the paper. “I have a duty to my country. I have a duty to my conscience.”

The IRS has sent him numerous warnings over unpaid taxes from 2002 to 2014, and in 2012 the Oregon Department of Revenue began garnishing money from Bowman’s bank account. In response, he started cashing out his paychecks and leaving only a minimum balance in his account.

This, federal prosecutors say, constituted “remov[ing] his income from the reach of taxing authorities.” They indicted him for felony tax evasion in the amount of $356,857, as well as four misdemeanor counts of willful failure to file tax returns.

Bowman’s attorney, Matthew Schindler, argued that his client was fully transparent every step of the way, from disclosing all of his paychecks to cashing them at his own bank, under his own name.

"Like a player collapsing as they lose Twister, the government has reached too far forward and stretched way too far back,'' his motion to dismiss read.

Last week, US District Judge Michael Mosman sided with Bowman on the felony charge, ruling that the feds failed to show he attempted to conceal income or deceive the government. Prosecutors remain free to re-introduce the charge in the future, and are currently weighing whether to do so.

On Tuesday, Bowman elaborated on his stand in an interview with CBN News.

"First, I would love to pay taxes so as to have a normal life, however, our government is using the tax dollars to fund Planned Parenthood; which commits abortions - the death of the innocent," Bowman said. “Apparently, a woman has the right to choose, but evidently, I do not.”

He also took aim at the common rejoinder that every American citizen has to pay taxes for things with which they might personally disagree, such as war. “You see, the Constitution grants certain abilities to the government, e.g. funding the military, but killing children is not a Constitutional backed, compelling interest of the government by any stretch of the imagination,” Bowman explained.

Planned Parenthood receives more than $500 million per year from the federal government, and performs more than 300,000 abortions. Federal law forbids taxpayer dollars from being directly spent on abortions, though pro-life groups argue that the money still enables abortion facilities to grow their reach and influence, and spend more revenue from other sources on abortions.

“All the government has to do is put a check box on the tax forms that says check here to support Planned Parenthood, and write in your donation amount," Bowman proposed. "Then, just like any church or charity, Planned Parenthood will be funded by those that have no problem with it, and the 150 million people like me that are pro-life, can pay their taxes and live knowing we kept our conscience clean.”

He vowed that he will continue his resistance as long as the government continues funding the abortion industry.

“My effort [is] about standing up, standing firm for my Constitutional rights, and getting the government to honor title 42 Chapter 21.b The Religious Freedom Restoration Act, so that I may live a peaceful life, and in the end face God, and hopefully have Him say, 'Well done, good and faithful servant!" he said.


https://www.lifesitenews.com/news/us-christian-who-refuses-to-pay-taxes-until-abortion-is-defunded-has-first

Cap
02-20-2019, 08:29 AM
Interesting, but I can't see the government allowing a precedent like this to get any kind of footing. This poor bastard will probably end up committing suicide after child porn is found on his computer or having some kind of unfortunate accident. They can't cede any ground on this.

juleswin
02-20-2019, 08:39 AM
Interesting, but I can't see the government allowing a precedent like this to get any kind of footing. This poor bastard will probably end up committing suicide after child porn is found on his computer or having some kind of unfortunate accident. They can't cede any ground on this.

Yea, I see no way they lose this case. Cos if they win, I am not paying taxes until they stop using force to collect taxes :)

Superfluous Man
02-20-2019, 11:01 AM
He also took aim at the common rejoinder that every American citizen has to pay taxes for things with which they might personally disagree, such as war. “You see, the Constitution grants certain abilities to the government, e.g. funding the military, but killing children is not a Constitutional backed, compelling interest of the government by any stretch of the imagination,” Bowman explained.


So all they would have to do is amend the Constitution to authorize the government to fund abortion and that would magically make it right for you to pay for it, like with paying for unjust actions of the military?

specsaregood
02-20-2019, 11:20 AM
So all they would have to do is amend the Constitution to authorize the government to fund abortion and that would magically make it right for you to pay for it, like with paying for unjust actions of the military?

No, it just means he would have to adjust his argument. You choose the best argument for the current conditions you live under.

PAF
02-20-2019, 11:20 AM
I just got this response from another board:



So why dont we do it?


Most people are employees and their taxes are paid through the employer payroll deductions, so most people cannot refuse to pay their taxes.

But people can refuse to file their 1040. Send in a blank 1040 with something like "As long as the government used my taxes to fund abortion via Planned Parenthood, I refuse to file because funding abortion is a substantial burden on my religious beliefs, per the Religious Freedom Restoration Act".

Yes you still pay your taxes and not sending in a 1040 sounds trivial - but the government runs on forms. Imagine if 50 million people simply did not send in their form. The bureaucracy would go nuts, they would have 50 million cases to deal with, they would be utterly swamped.





Anybody in???


:up:

brushfire
02-20-2019, 11:44 AM
A sushi menu - that's how it should be done. What government services are you willing to pay for?

euphemia
02-20-2019, 12:07 PM
They might be surprised.

jkr
02-20-2019, 12:22 PM
Wait... principals are deductible?

euphemia
02-20-2019, 12:34 PM
Wait... principals are deductible?

No, principles. :kiss:

jkr
02-20-2019, 01:20 PM
No, principles. :kiss:

I eng in ear me no spel

Zippyjuan
02-20-2019, 02:35 PM
The ruling didn't decide if he owed taxes or not but only that he was not "deceptive" about not paying them.

https://www.oregonlive.com/portland/2018/04/judges_tosses_out_felony_tax_e.html#incart_target2 box_default_#incart_target2box_targeted_


U.S. District Judge Michael W. Mosman ruled that the government's indictment failed to provide any evidence that Michael Bowman tried to conceal or mislead government officials by simply cashing his checks and keeping a low bank balance so tax collectors couldn't garnish his account to pay taxes.


"I'm not a tax protester. I love my country. I have a duty to my country. I have a duty to my conscience,'' the 53-year-old said, raising his hand and striking his chest, where the front of his shirt spelled out a definition of "conscience."


Bowman still faces four counts of willful failure to file tax returns, a misdemeanor.

jkr
02-20-2019, 06:04 PM
If everyone did it...

oyarde
02-20-2019, 06:12 PM
I already have to pay no taxes . Should I demand a refund of past taxes paid if they continue ?

PAF
02-20-2019, 06:29 PM
Wilson responded back to me on the other forum:



Wilson wrote:

I called several people at the National Right to Life Committee to see if they would help spread the word. I don't have much faith they will but maybe.....



Anybody else here care to help?

Zippyjuan
02-20-2019, 06:49 PM
Does he also protest taxes being used by the military to kill people?