PDA

View Full Version : Why Do Trump and Rubio Still Favor Cheap Foreign Labor?




Brian4Liberty
02-19-2016, 02:49 PM
Why Do Trump and Rubio Still Favor Cheap Foreign Labor? (https://www.conservativereview.com/commentary/2016/02/why-do-trump-and-rubio-still-favor-cheap-foreign-labor)
By: Daniel Horowitz | February 16, 2016


What is remarkable about the 2016 presidential election process thus far is the sheer volume of important questions that have not been asked. While the leftist media is busy asking candidates about their shoes, the things the American people should know—indeed, need to know—before they vote in the primaries and again in the fall never seem to come up.

In keeping with this pattern of discussing nonsense over substance, two of the candidates running for the Republican presidential nomination, Marco Rubio and Donald Trump, have never been asked to fully explain their position on foreign workers: Why do they both support the importation and use of cheap foreign labor, and the displacement of American employees?

While Rubio is widely known for his comprehensive amnesty bill, his name is also on another atrocious and much more recent immigration bill. He has yet to be asked about it at a debate or in any major forum on the campaign trail. In January 2015, Rubio joined Senator Orrin Hatch (R-Utah) as an original co-sponsor of a bill that is deceptively named the Immigration Innovation (or “I-Squared”) Act. The only original thing about this bill is that its supporters have innovatively prevented the American people from noticing how economically destructive it would be if it ever became law.

The I-Squared Act calls for a dramatic increase in the number of foreign workers that can be brought into the United States under the H-1B visa program.
...
With that in mind, you will be happy to know that the Hatch-Rubio I-Squared Act … proposes precisely zero reforms to the H-1B program and calls for a more-than-threefold increase in H-1B visas.
...
Rubio’s continued support of the I-Squared Act is particularly mind-boggling given the public relations meltdown and subsequent class action litigation against ABC-Disney for its termination of literally hundreds of Disney IT workers in Orlando and its subsequent replacement of them with H-1B foreign labor.
...
Ted Cruz also got roped into the ridiculous quest for more H-1B visas when he first entered the Senate and signed onto ridiculous legislation to expand the program. But at least he has been moved by the Disney scandal and has sponsored legislation with Sen. Sessions to reform the program. We can ask legitimate questions about whether Cruz’s conversion is part of his broader, strong record on immigration or simply a campaign pander, but the bigger question is which other candidates are still bad on the issue, despite the publically-reported scandals.

Trump’s campaign has lobbed fire at Rubio for the latter’s unapologetic, pro-corporatist support for the H-1B program generally and the I-Squared Act specifically. But Trump himself has used quite a few foreign visa programs in his day to hire cheaper foreign workers instead of Americans, and he needs to be asked about that as well.

More specifically, Trump has been, and continues to be, an all-too-frequent user of several foreign visa programs. This is not conjecture but fact: according to Business Insider, an earlier Reuters investigation determined that U.S. Department of Labor records show that nine companies that are majority-owned by Trump have imported at least 1,100 foreign workers on temporary visas since 2000. While some of these visas are for fashion models, he has brought hundreds of others in to do jobs that Americans would do: waitresses, cooks, event managers, and even an assistant golf course superintendent.

For those who are curious, Trump is still using these visa programs to bring in foreign workers, his campaign rhetoric aside. According to this same report, Trump’s posh Palm Beach, Florida luxury resort, Mar-a-Lago, filed paperwork with the Department of Labor last July—in other words, in 2015—to bring in 70 foreign workers to work at Mar-a-Lago. These are jobs that Americans could have right now. (Mar-a-Lago appears to have brought in as many as 787 foreign workers since 2006, by the way.)

Trump needs to explain his use of foreign worker visa programs, particularly given his chest-thumping but detail-free pronouncements about how he will be the greatest jobs-producing president ever.
...
More: https://www.conservativereview.com/commentary/2016/02/why-do-trump-and-rubio-still-favor-cheap-foreign-labor

P3ter_Griffin
02-19-2016, 03:14 PM
Awww... Cruz has been moved by the Disney 'scandal'. AmericanSpartan will be happy to know.

The author conflates business ethics with political philosophy... Typical for the leftist.

RonPaulMall
02-19-2016, 08:21 PM
Trump is probably bringing in Eastern Europeans to work at Mar-a-Lago because they are more presentable and speak better English than the "Americans" that comprise the South Florida entry labor market.

Zippyjuan
02-19-2016, 08:46 PM
Maybe we should have a minimum wage for immigrants so they don't undercut wages of civilians? Or a minimum wage for everybody to keep wages from falling too much? Or should an employer be able to hire whomever he want to at whatever wage that person is willing to work for?