PDA

View Full Version : Junior high teacher tells kid to remove Marines t-shirt or get suspended




aGameOfThrones
02-27-2013, 10:06 AM
The latest bit of anti-gun hysteria erupted in a school setting on Monday when an eighth-grade teacher threatened a 14-year-old boy with suspension if he did not remove his t-shirt supporting the United States Marines.

The incident occurred in a reading class at Genoa-Kingston Middle School in a small town in northeast Illinois. The teacher, Karen Deverell, believed the interlocking rifles emblazoned across Michael McIntyre’s shirt violated the school’s dress code, reports Fox News.

McIntyre’s father, Daniel McIntyre, said Deverell made him turn the shirt inside out for the rest of the day. He also noted that the boy had worn the shirt to school on many previous occasions without threats of suspension.

“My son is very proud of the Marines, and, in fact, of all the services,” the elder McIntyre told Fox News. “So he wears it with pride. There are two rifles crossed underneath the word ‘Marines’ on the shirt, but to me that should be overlooked. It’s more about the Marines instead of the rifles.”

Daniel McIntyre added that his son was upset about the situation.

“He couldn’t understand why a teacher would make him do that,” he said.

According to a local newspaper, school officials (beyond the teacher) had not been aware of the kerfuffle until Fox News — which had the story first — notified administrators late Monday.

Superintendent Joe Burgess told the DeKalb Daily Chronicle that Deverell’s superiors would have immediately overruled the teacher’s interpretation of the school district’s dress code had they known about it.

“Very simply, it’s not a violation,” Burgess told the Daily Chronicle. “It’s a very common symbol for the U.S. Marines. Had we had an opportunity to discuss it, we could have straightened out the situation.”



http://news.yahoo.com/junior-high-teacher-tells-kid-remove-marines-t-123355966.html

belian78
02-27-2013, 10:27 AM
Something like this happening in a burb of Chicago? Surely they jest! :rolleyes:

cjm
02-27-2013, 10:55 AM
Superintendent Joe Burgess told the DeKalb Daily Chronicle that Deverell’s superiors would have immediately overruled the teacher’s interpretation of the school district’s dress code had they known about it.

“Very simply, it’s not a violation,” Burgess told the Daily Chronicle. “It’s a very common symbol for the U.S. Marines. Had we had an opportunity to discuss it, we could have straightened out the situation.”

Promoting the federal government and its goals gets confusing sometimes. For any teachers out there that have made similar mistakes, here's a rough guide on how to handle these situations.

On one hand, there's what the government is, and on the other hand there's what the government does. Do not put a higher priority on does (push for gun bans) instead of what it is (USMC is part of the federal government). Defending the existence of any federal organization is more important than defending federal government goals. That's what you need to keep in mind. Rejecting a Marine Corps shirt might be interpreted as rejecting the legitimacy of the Corps itself.

The Marine Corps t-shirt gets a pass because they are part of the federal government. If a similar logo was used on an Illinois Militia t-shirt, then you can ban the shirt. I hope this helps.

Expatriate
02-27-2013, 11:01 AM
^^ Yep, if it was a "2nd Amendment" or militia shirt it would be a no go and probably a suspension, but supporting the standing army the 2nd Amdmt. was meant to keep in check is just fine and dandy.

Mani
02-27-2013, 07:58 PM
^^ Yep, if it was a "2nd Amendment" or militia shirt it would be a no go and probably a suspension, but supporting the standing army the 2nd Amdmt. was meant to keep in check is just fine and dandy.


Lol, expulsion and the family probably gets a swat team visit due to anonymous drug tip.....Lol.

noneedtoaggress
02-27-2013, 08:26 PM
Promoting the federal government and its goals gets confusing sometimes. For any teachers out there that have made similar mistakes, here's a rough guide on how to handle these situations.

On one hand, there's what the government is, and on the other hand there's what the government does. Do not put a higher priority on does (push for gun bans) instead of what it is (USMC is part of the federal government). Defending the existence of any federal organization is more important than defending federal government goals. That's what you need to keep in mind. Rejecting a Marine Corps shirt might be interpreted as rejecting the legitimacy of the Corps itself.

The Marine Corps t-shirt gets a pass because they are part of the federal government. If a similar logo was used on an Illinois Militia t-shirt, then you can ban the shirt. I hope this helps.

Exactly. +rep

Govt propaganda advertising gets a free pass. In fact it's not PC to even question.

seraphson
02-27-2013, 09:04 PM
Kerfuffle.


teehee