PDA

View Full Version : % Of Private Sector Folks In Each POTUS cabinet




Revolution9
07-31-2012, 09:46 AM
"Some of these Presidents were not very Liberty loving but most all worked in the private sector. All but one!
The percentage of each past president's cabinet who had worked in the private business sector prior to their appointment to the cabinet. You know that the private business sector is a real-life business, not a government job. Here are the percentages.
T. Roosevelt.................... 38%
Taft.................................. 40%
Wilson ........................... 52%
Harding........................... 49%
Coolidge......................... 48%
Hoover............................ 42%
F. Roosevelt................... 50%
Truman........................... 50%
Eisenhower................ .... 57%
Kennedy......................... 30%
Johnson.......................... 47%
Nixon.............................. 53%
Ford................................ 42%
Carter............................. 32%
Reagan........................... 56%
GH Bush......................... 51%
Clinton .......................... 39%
GW Bush........................ 55%
Obama.............................. 8%
This helps to explain the incompetence of this administration: only 8% of them have ever worked in private business!"

Rev9

kathy88
07-31-2012, 10:08 AM
Nice find Rev.

Acala
07-31-2012, 10:51 AM
I wonder what that would look like if you excluded crony capitalist "businesses" like banks? Not so one-sided I'll wager.

2young2vote
07-31-2012, 01:02 PM
Is this directly before their appointment to the cabinet, or is this the % of people who have EVER had a job in the private sector prior to their appointment?

Revolution9
07-31-2012, 01:45 PM
Is this directly before their appointment to the cabinet, or is this the % of people who have EVER had a job in the private sector prior to their appointment?

Not sure. Just thought the stats were amusing. Cheney was in the private sector as well as the government sector simultaneously was my first thought.. Used to be you would draft the best minds from various industries.. that of course has changed and was not an absolute but an aspiration.

Rev9

Feeding the Abscess
07-31-2012, 02:12 PM
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UNxgdoXtQGM&feature=plcp

Aratus
08-01-2012, 04:41 AM
neat

Zippyjuan
08-01-2012, 10:33 AM
That claim was debunked and the creater has taken it down but it still circulates.
http://mediamatters.org/research/2009/12/03/gingrich-pushes-debunked-claim-on-private-secto/157698

In Obama's Cabinet, at least three of the nine posts that Cembalest and Beck cite -- a full one-third -- are occupied by appointees who, by our reading of their bios, had significant corporate or business experience. Shaun Donovan, Obama's secretary of Housing and Urban Development, served as managing director of Prudential Mortgage Capital Co., where he oversaw its investments in affordable housing loans.

Energy Secretary Steven Chu headed the electronics research lab at one of America's storied corporate research-and-development facilities, AT&T Bell Laboratories, where his work won a Nobel Prize for physics. And Interior Secretary Ken Salazar, in addition to serving as Colorado attorney general and a U.S. senator, has been a partner in his family's farm for decades and, with his wife, owned and operated a Dairy Queen and radio stations in his home state of Colorado.

Three other Obama appointees had legal experience in the private sector.

Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton, Agriculture Secretary Tom Vilsack and Commerce Secretary Gary Locke spent part of their careers working as lawyers in private practice. Clinton and Vilsack worked as private-sector lawyers at the beginning of their careers, while Locke joined an international law firm, Davis Wright Tremaine LLP, after serving as governor of Washington state. At the firm, Locke "co-chaired the firm's China practice" and "helped U.S. companies break into international markets," according to his official biography. That sounds like real private sector experience to us.

Finally, Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner worked for Kissinger Associates, a consulting firm that advises international corporations on political and economic conditions overseas.

The occupants of the two remaining Cabinet posts cited in the chart do not appear to have had significant private-sector experience: Labor Secretary Hilda Solis and Transportation Secretary Ray LaHood.

Obama's Cabinet has even more private-sector experience if you go beyond the nine. Two of the Obama appointees could be considered entrepreneurs -- the very people Beck would "unleash." Vice President Joe Biden, officially a Cabinet member, founded his own law firm, Biden and Walsh, early in his career, and it still exists in a later incarnation, Monzack Mersky McLaughlin and Browder, P.A. (The future vice president also supplemented his income by managing properties, including a neighborhood swimming pool.) And Office of Management and Budget director Peter Orszag founded an economic consulting firm called Sebago Associates that was later bought out by a larger firm.

It's also worth noting that if you examine a larger group of senior Obama administration appointees, you'll find that more than one in four have experience as business executives, according to a June study by National Journal. That compared with the 38 percent the magazine found eight years earlier at the start of George W. Bush's administration. That's at least three times higher than the level claimed by Beck.



Chart accompanying study was circulated by conservative blogs. In a November 24 Forbes.com article about his study, Cembalest included a chart which compared the Obama administration's "Prior Private Sector Experience" to the appointees of presidents. After the chart was featured by Nick Schulz on the American Enterprise Institute's blog, it was picked up by numerous other prominent conservative blogs, including National Review Online's The Corner, The Washington Examiner's blog, Outside the Beltway, Big Government, Reason's Hit & Run, and the blog of House Republican Leader John Boehner.

After posting Cembalest's graph, The Volokh Conspiracy "decided to take it down." Law professor Kenneth Anderson wrote in a December 2 update to a Volokh Conspiracy blog post: "After discussions with the person who created the chart, I've decided to take it down and the rest of my commentary as well. He tells me that he has had a chance to re-think the whole thing, and thinks it was a big mistake to try and quantify with a graph things -- in this case, what constitutes private sector experience -- that are inherently subjective."