PDA

View Full Version : Auburn Univ. Orders Student to Take Down Ron Paul Poster




bobbyw24
12-26-2011, 12:56 PM
Who cares? This school has a great football program and ain't that wut college is all about?

When someone complained about a student’s Ron Paul poster in his dorm room window this fall, Auburn University in Alabama had the opportunity to take a principled stand for free speech. Of course, since we’re dealing with a university, you can probably guess that it instead chose to double down on an unwise, needlessly restrictive, and unfairly enforced policy at odds with the spirit of the First Amendment.

Auburn undergrad Eric Philips probably thought he wasn’t doing anything particularly noteworthy when he hung a banner supporting Representative Ron Paul’s presidential candidacy in his residence hall window. ’Tis the eve of election season, after all. On November 7, however, Philips’s hall director ordered him to remove the banner from his window — an order with which Philips complied. A housing administrator explained to Philips Auburn’s policy (new this year) on window postings, which states that “Hanging or displaying items such as flags, banners, decals, or signs out of or obstructing residence hall windows is prohibited.”

Yet Auburn was not swayed. Instead, Assistant Vice President for Student Affairs Amy Hecht’s reply to FIRE failed to acknowledge its selective policy enforcement, while maintaining that Auburn was “committed to the consistent and nondiscriminatory enforcement of this policy.” This represents a missed opportunity for Auburn, and one which puts it out of step with America’s understanding of free speech. As the Supreme Court famously wrote in Healy v. James (1972), “the vigilant protection of constitutional freedoms is nowhere more vital than in the community of American schools.”

Read more: http://dailycaller.com/2011/12/22/whos-afraid-of-ron-paul-apparently-auburn-university/#ixzz1hfWJ3vLX

jcarcinogen
12-26-2011, 01:00 PM
In his dorm room window?! A shame that the city of Auburn, AL is the home of the Mises Institute too. :(

bobbyw24
12-26-2011, 01:02 PM
Philips contacted FIRE, which sent a letter to Auburn President Jay Gogue on December 9, informing him of the unconstitutional double standard apparently in place at Auburn and of the evidence in FIRE's possession. FIRE wrote, "Such selective enforcement and viewpoint-based discrimination is untenable at Auburn, a public university bound by the First Amendment. Auburn must evenly enforce its policies on student expression."

FIRE's letter also reminded President Gogue that during the 2008 election season, the University of Texas at Austin attempted to enforce a similar policy banning all signs in residence hall windows. Two students were ordered to remove campaign signs from their windows or else be blocked from class registration. The resulting uproar led UT-Austin President William Powers Jr. to suspend the rule indefinitely, saying, "I believe that the free expression of ideas is crucial to our educational mission." The University of Alabama also abandoned a ban on window displays in 2003 after students protested the ban by hanging American flags all over a dormitory.

So far, Auburn's response has been disappointing. Auburn Assistant Vice President for Student Affairs Amy Hecht responded to FIRE on December 13, failing to acknowledge that what she called a "total ban" on window displays had been selectively enforced but insisting that Auburn is "committed to the consistent and nondiscriminatory enforcement of this policy."

"As other universities have recognized, a total ban on window displays is an unjustifiable and unnecessary restraint on expression. Auburn has given no reason for its ‘total ban' on such displays, which are a part of campus culture at colleges across America," said FIRE Senior Vice President Robert Shibley. "It's time for Auburn to admit that a ban on expression like this is not only wrong, it's ripe for abuse—and it's being abused."

http://thefire.org/article/13968.html

kpitcher
12-26-2011, 01:57 PM
Anyone around to take photos of dorm room windows? Should be easy to find someone with oh, a school logo visible. They'd look ridiculous having to stop school spirit but would have to or have a double standard.

Sublyminal
12-26-2011, 02:01 PM
Anyone around to take photos of dorm room windows? Should be easy to find someone with oh, a school logo visible. They'd look ridiculous having to stop school spirit but would have to or have a double standard.


Someone needs to do that and then demand that it be removed by the school.