PDA

View Full Version : is Bob Gates calling for a military draft?




cindy25
09-29-2010, 11:01 PM
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2010/09/29/robert-gates-war-burdens-too-few-bear_n_744536.html



DURHAM, N.C. — Defense Secretary Robert Gates said Wednesday that most Americans have grown too detached from the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan and see military service as "something for other people to do."

In a speech Wednesday at Duke University, Gates said this disconnect has imposed a heavy burden on a small segment of society and wildly driven up the costs of maintaining an all-volunteer force.

Because fewer Americans see military service as their duty, troops today face repeated combat tours and long separations from family. The 2.4 million people serving in the armed forces today represent less than 1 percent of the country's total population.

To attract and retain recruits, the Defense Department finds itself spending more money, including handsome bonuses and education benefits. The money spent on personnel and benefits has nearly doublince the 2001 invasion of Afghanistan, from $90 billion to $170 billion.

"That is our sacred obligation," Gates told the audience of compensating troops. "But given the enormous fiscal pressures facing the country," the nation must devise "an equitable and sustainable system of military pay and benefits that reflects the realities of this century."

Gates, who plans to retire next year, has been using academic-style speeches to outline what he believes to be the nation's toughest challenges that lie ahead when it comes to defense.

Earlier this year, Gates asked whether troops were training for the right kinds of missions and called into question the utility of D-Day style amphibious landings handled historically by the Marine Corps. He has also embarked on a cost-cutting initiative to prepare for what he says are leaner days ahead for the department.

As is the case in most of these speeches, Gates on Wednesday tried to raise awareness about a long-term problem rather than solve it. He offered no plan for what he described as a growing divide between Americans in uniform and those who aren't.

"Whatever their fond sentiments for men and women in uniform, for most Americans the war remains an abstraction – a distant and unpleasant series of news items that do not affect them personally," Gates said.

Austrian Econ Disciple
09-29-2010, 11:07 PM
Actually it does affect us personally you idiot. You don't think spending a trillion dollars + a year affects us? You don't think loss of liberty because of war affects us? These buffoons are laudable for their complete ignorance -- alas, their ignorance effects us all.

Fozz
09-29-2010, 11:12 PM
Actually it does affect us personally you idiot. You don't think spending a trillion dollars + a year affects us? You don't think loss of liberty because of war affects us? These buffoons are laudable for their complete ignorance -- alas, their ignorance effects us all.

It affects us because we are informed and educated about the dangers of excessive intervention, and the death and destruction it causes, as well as the cost.

Most of the GOP and Tea Party is too dumb to see the connection between an aggressive foreign policy and the loss of liberty.

Promontorium
09-29-2010, 11:39 PM
Civillian employees of the Federal government are paid much much more, and have much much lower standards to adhere to. This is scare reporting at its most ludicrous. The draft will never return. They don't even want the people they have now. That "less than 1%" is one of the largest militaries in the world, not counting Reservists, not counting contractors. Ridiculous. The lot of you.

cindy25
09-30-2010, 01:41 AM
these are Huffington post comments:

OregonDoug
Bring back the draft.

emiliob6 2
I totally agree, when politicians know that if they start a war their sons or daughters will be called to fight it, they will not be so quick in voting for it...

carnitine
Women better be forced to serve. Tired of double standard

and since Beck's Blaze has the same article with different comments, I also looked there

and Beck readers are as much against the draft as Huff post readers favor it