How would Rand Paul and Peter Schiff vote on Kagan?

[cindy25]

have either made a comment?
they are both running for senate and should issue a statement

[low preference guy]

it's an easy no vote.

[sofia]

Kagan = Communist

[cindy25]

I want to hear both of them say they would vote no

[TheBlackPeterSchiff]

Schiff has said repeatedly that he would not support anyone who doesn't show strict support for the Constitution and what the Founders meant it should be, a restraint for government.

[cindy25]

Schiff has said repeatedly that he would not support anyone who doesn't show strict support for the Constitution and what the Founders meant it should be, a restraint for government.

then he should issue a statement condemning the Kagan appointment. issue it NOW

[TCE]

then he should issue a statement condemning the Kagan appointment. issue it NOW

I despise him, but Mark Kirk gave a great statement on her: "There is a confirmation process for a reason. I will wait until I hear what she has to say, then I will make my mind up. Senators should not be jumping to her support or against her just yet."

[cindy25]

I despise him, but Mark Kirk gave a great statement on her: "There is a confirmation process for a reason. I will wait until I hear what she has to say, then I will make my mind up. Senators should not be jumping to her support or against her just yet."

the SC is different. there can be a bandwagon effect led by Graham/Lieberman.

Schiff, being Jewish, and from the Northeast, and saying he would vote NO could have an effect on fence sitting Rep senators

[low preference guy]

Schiff has said that he would've voted against all judges except Bork, the Reagan nominee who didn't get confirmed.