Three Ron Paul Commercials - Which is the Best?

[FrankRep]

Edit: It was working earlier, sorry.



Columbus, Ohio will start running Commercials in October.

The question is: which commercial is the most effective?
These commercials aren't the final draft so don't worry.



Which commercial is the most effective?

http://www.spotrunner.com/Ads/Host/Play.aspx?cde=A1PK
http://www.spotrunner.com/Ads/Host/Play.aspx?cde=AQGE
http://www.alcpac.com/rp_30sec_ver4.mov

Opinions?

[ItsTime]

errors on the first two

[trispear]

I like the 3rd one, of course it's the only one I was able to watch^_^

[LibertyEagle]

Watch them here:
http://www.operationnh.com/commercials.html


Oops. Nevermind. They're messed up here too.

[JosephTheLibertarian]

I'd say the 3rd.. the first two a bit of a bore lol

note - the first two have errors ;)

[G-khan]

Watch them here:
http://www.operationnh.com/commercials.html


Oops. Nevermind. They're messed up here too.

Still get the errors ?

[Ozwest]

I could only get the third one up. Looked good, but the audio sounded a little choppy.

[G-khan]

I could only get the third one up. Looked good, but the audio sounded a little choppy.

I agree the audio needs some work..

[terlinguatx]

...

[TechnoGuyRob]

I liked it, but the children overlaps seemed a bit...

Well, I mean, if I was hearing about him for the first time, like that, I'd think "hmm...that just sounds like something to force my attention. That certainly turns me off..."

Don't know though, what do others think?

[Lord Xar]

well, I am working like a dog to get "2" additional ones. I would wait before you make a decision. You have till the 10th before you have to "make a decision".

[LibertyEagle]

I liked it, but the children overlaps seemed a bit...

Well, I mean, if I was hearing about him for the first time, like that, I'd think "hmm...that just sounds like something to force my attention. That certainly turns me off..."

Don't know though, what do others think?

I agree. I like the original version much more than this one. All the different voices, with some overlapping, makes it very difficult to concentrate on what if being said. I thought the original version was much more touching. I did think it would have been better if it had been re-recorded with a professional voice, but compared to the latest version, I'd take the 1st version any day.

[Ozwest]

I agree. I like the original version much more than this one. All the different voices, with some overlapping, makes it very difficult to concentrate on what if being said. I thought the original version was much more touching. I did think it would have been better if it had been re-recorded with a professional voice, but compared to the latest version, I'd take the 1st version any day.

Agreed. It's hard to absorb in 30 seconds, even harder if you're not "tuning" in.

[0zzy]

get rid of the child
she doesnt know anything

[Ozwest]

get rid of the child
she doesnt know anything

oooohh but I thought she was soooo cute. LOL