Hypothetical: Would a North American Union solve illegal immigration?

[Starks]

If Canada, Mexico, and the U.S. became a single socioeconomic entity, wouldn't all notions of citizenship be resolved?

[Kregener]

Yes, they would.

And that pesky "sovereignty" issue would be "solved" too.

And that annoying 2nd Amendment thingy.

And all three could become bankrupt as they attempted to spread the MASSIVE American debt out among the three.

[Original_Intent]

Well, since sovereignty would be in the toilet, I guess citizenship would be a non-issue.

Of course, we could just accept one-world gubmint and then there would be no more wars because there would be no one left to fight against.

[G-khan]

If Canada, Mexico, and the U.S. became a single socioeconomic entity, wouldn't all notions of citizenship be resolved?

Yes and it would also be the end of The United States and our sovereignty. U.S.A. as a free and independent nation would be one step closer to NWO

[Starks]

But how would the NAU ever be legalized? How would it manifest itself? Would it be a "behind the scenes" kind of thing or completely transparent like the EU?

[fluoridatedbrainsoup]

The N.A.U. will be a de facto reality for several years before a crisis allows them to formally declare it. Just because it aint in the news, don't mean it's not here already.

[constituent]

The N.A.U. will be a de facto reality for several years before a crisis allows them to formally declare it. Just because it aint in the news, don't mean it's not here already.

QFT

[Bryan]

No, it would not solve the issue of illegal immigration since you could still have illegal's coming from places other than North America. Only two things would eliminate illegal immigration:
- Make all immigration legal, of any means. i.e. no process, just come in- this is the diehard libertarian approach.
- Form an all encompassing union such as a world body. (But this still leaves one open to extraterrestrial illegal immigrants. :) )

Not that I'm advancing either idea, just saying...

[Hardrock]

Well, the thinking behind it is weak, to say the least, but there have been
extensive studies that claim a benefit.

Sort of like removing all the doors from your house results in a dramatic
decrease in "breaking and entering."


.

[Truth Warrior]

The "official" allowing of illegal immigration is merely a stealth tactical implementation mechanism of the NAU. We don't need "immigration reform" we need "ILLEGAL immigration reform".

[jmdrake]

But how would the NAU ever be legalized? How would it manifest itself? Would it be a "behind the scenes" kind of thing or completely transparent like the EU?

The European Union started off as "behind the scenes". And they are still lying to the people about what is going on. See:

http://timesonline.typepad.com/rees_mogg/2006/05/a_constitution_.html

[gaazn]

yes, it would make all the mexican illegal immigrants legal. but not so much luck for the asian, african, and european illegals.

[norak]

Yes and it would also be the end of The United States and our sovereignty. U.S.A. as a free and independent nation would be one step closer to NWO

That's not necessarily a bad thing for us if this New World Order is Libertarian.


Form an all encompassing union such as a world body. (But this still leaves one open to extraterrestrial illegal immigrants. )Then they would really be illegal aliens.

[stilltrying]

these are my thoughts on the NAU, whether right or wrong this is what im thinking. This is being done to further erode the middle class and have only upper and lower classes. Once you have this then you will have superiors and subordinates. Subordinates are slaves who work for 60 hours a week, get paid very little and are told by the masters that if they dont produce then you will be useless to society and therefore be gotten rid of. No medicare or medicaid, once you are useless in a socialist state you are no longer valuable to the state and therefore are using to many resources with no purpose for the socialist state.

[ronpaulblogsdotcom]

If Canada, Mexico, and the U.S. became a single socioeconomic entity, wouldn't all notions of citizenship be resolved?

3 thoughts:

Yes it would, but you as an American probably would not like how it is done.

Starks is still banned.

Please dont bump a thread where the OP has been banned.