PDA

View Full Version : Missing Segment on second airing of debate




PimpBlimp
01-25-2008, 09:29 AM
I am looking for the part where the reporter in the audience asks Giuliani about the hypocrisy of him wanting to require illegal aliens to learn english yet he airs his ads in Spanish.

It is missing from all 3 uploaded video composites of the debate on youtube so I am guessing they edited it out of the second airing.


it should be in these videos but it is not.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_xjx8M_X9EA
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-2y1-PGoawQ

I need help locating this segment or at least finding a transcript of the 1st airing of the debate.

PimpBlimp
01-25-2008, 09:40 AM
Nevermind I found it.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V5GalmsET0k


MR. TASH: Mayor Giuliani, this question to you comes from Marshall Brennan (sp) of St. Petersburg.

"Your immigration plan calls for all immigrants to learn English to gain citizenship. So why is your campaign airing an ad in Spanish?" (Laughter.)

MR. GIULIANI: (Laughs.) The reality is I believe that America is a country that is built around the English language. If you want to become a citizen, you should demonstrate your facility with English. If you know other languages, that is wonderful. That's a wonderful thing. And if we have substantial portions of populations that know other languages, I'm very comfortable trying to reach them in both English and in Spanish.

The core of my plan on immigration is to stop illegal immigration at the border with a border stat system, with technology, with an increased Border Patrol. I believe we can stop illegal immigration if we stop it right at the border.

And then we should develop a tamper-proof ID card so that people who want to come into the United States should be allowed to do that. We need to teach new behavior. The new behavior is, if you want to come into the United States, you have to identify yourself -- which, after all, makes the United States like every other country, right?

You can't get into most countries without identifying yourself. And then if you've got the tamper-proof ID card, you'd be allowed to work, pay taxes, get online, become a citizen, follow the rules, but then at the end of the line, you'd have to be able to read, write and speak English.

If you speak a second language or a third language or a fourth language, I think that's great for America. I think America has to be a country that has facility with more languages, given the global economy we live in. And I think we can be very comfortable with that, but the focus has to be on being able to read, write and speak English if you want to be a citizen.

http://www.nytimes.com/2008/01/24/us/politics/24text-debate.html?pagewanted=print